Lim Kit Siang

Universiti Putra Malaysia (UPM) Vice Chancellor Nik Mustapha should publicly apologise for the baseless charge that student activist Yee Yang Yang had pornographic material in his laptop and ensure free and fair student campus elections so as not to attract for the UPM the epithet of Mat Rempit University.

I commend the UPM for owning up to “flaws” in the Mat Rempit-action by the UPM security unit in its high-handed arrogance in confiscating Yee’s laptop, mobile phone, MP3 player and 10 other items valued at RM6,000 during a spot check of his hostel room but what is unpardonable and inexcusable is the lie that Yee had pornographic material in his laptop.

I do not believe that this lie was concocted by the Vice Chancellor but he would have relied on it based on a report by the security unit, which had no password to access Yee’s notebook.

I do not call for Nik Mustapha’s resignation as UPM Vice Chancellor although this is a grave mistake but he should at least publicly apologise for his error and misjudgment in running an university administration where his departmental heads and officers are not aware of the importance of truth and integrity. In the process, they have brought brought UPM into public shame and disrepute.

Apart from his public apology to Yee for the lie about pornographic material in the notebook, he must take disciplinary action against the security personnel for their Mat Rempit behaviour against UPM students, whether anti or pro-establishment, including expulsion of the security officer who had embarrassed him and UPM publicly in telling the lie against Yee.

With the campus student elections on Oct 2 and nomination today, Nik Mustapha should take special pains to ensure that UPM will be an exemplary university where student elections are held in a free and fair manner so that the epithet of Mat Rempit University will not stick to UPM under his Vice Chancellorship.

In this connection, I call on the Higher Education Minister, Datuk Mustapha Mohamed to take the first bold step to give meaning and substance to the National Higher Education Action Plan 2007-2010 to start the long journey to make Malaysia a world leader in higher education by sending a clear message to all Vice Chancellors to hold free and fair campus elections in public universities and to respect and accept the election results.

Mustapha should de-politicise campus student elections by publicly declaring that as Higher Education Minister, he would not be partisan and would not take sides with any candidate or group of candidates contesting in the campus polls, and that he would not mind and would fully accept the verdict of the campus elections regardless of who wins or loses, so long as the campus elections are held in a free and fair manner.

He should announce a “hands-off” policy to ensure a vibrant, critical and creative student campus and scrap the secret agenda of Vice Chancellors and deputies to ensure victory of the compliant “pro-establishment” student groups.

One important reason why Malaysian public universities had been on a downward plunge as centres of academic excellence is because it has been drummed into the Vice Chancellors and their deputies that it is more important for their career future that they deliver campus elections to pro-establishment student groups rather than ensuring that the universities achieve international recognition as world-class universities as receiving top rankings in world tables, such as the Times Higher Education Supplement (THES) and the Shanghai Jiao Tong University annual listing of top world universities.

Let the 2007 public university student elections be the first which is fully de-politicised where students are allowed to elect, in a free and fair manner, the student leaders they want without any ulterior agenda from any political party to stack university student representative councils with their nominees.

Syed Jaymal Zahiid
Malaysiakini

University Putra Malaysia (UPM) has caved in to pressure by students and human rights groups and agreed to return the laptop it confiscated on Sept 15 from first-year student Yee Yang Yang, 19.

However, there is a catch - he will have to get the laptop and other personal belongings from the Sri Serdang police.

The university security unit had handed these over after Yee lodged a police report on Sept 17.

This morning, a 10-member delegation - representing students and civil society groups - met with corporate communication officer Abdullah Arshad and security unit head Othman Jailani.

The delegation was part of a group of 50 who had gathered outside the university and then marched peacefully to the entrance, where they were stopped by security personnel.

There was slight tension when DAP leader Ronnie Liu, who heads the party’s NGO Bureau, began arguing with two of the guards.

Suara Rakyat Malaysia secretariat member S Arutchelvan defused the tension by negotiating for a 10-member delegation to meet with a representative of the vice-chancellor.

They were then led to an office in the modern language studies faculty to hand over the six-page memorandum to Abdullah and Othman.

‘Procedures flawed’

Following this, Othman conceded that the confiscation procedure was flawed.

“We admit that there were flaws in the confiscation process and we will look into the matter. We welcome the suggestions made by everyone here,” he said.

Both Othman and Abdullah said the investigation involving Yee has ended and that the university wants an amicable solution to the matter which has seen students stand up to the campus authorities. They did not reveal the outcome of the probe.

Liu then suggested that UPM issues a letter informing the police that it had completed its investigation, in order to inform the police that there is no longer a need to hold Yee’s belongings

Othman agreed, also promising that he would do his best to amend the procedural flaws.

He further told the delegation that he was checking on the officers involved in the Sept 15 raid on Yee’s room, to determine if they had acted properly.

Yee, who was present, only said that he “was glad” that the issue had been settled.

He had previously denied UPM’s claims that the laptop had pornographic material in it - among other accusations - and attributed the incident instead to his leanings in student politics.

Rival students groups - dubbed ‘anti-establishment’ and ‘pro-government’- are preparing for campus elections on Oct 2 in all public universities.

Last year, the anti-establishment group - generally regarded as pro-opposition - had boycotted the election in protest of allegedly unfair procedures and intimidation by various campus authorities.

The Star

PUTRAJAYA: A group of about 1,000 lawyers gathered at the steps of the Palace of Justice here to march to the Prime Minister’s office.

The march, organised by the Bar Council, was to hand over a memorandum to the Prime Minister’s office, calling for a royal commission to investigate the authenticity of a video clip showing a senior lawyer purportedly brokering the appointment of judges with a senior judge.

Several buses ferrying lawyers from Kuala Lumpur turned up for the march.